W. Joseph Campbell

, , , , , , , ,

Carl Bernstein, naive and over the top

In Debunking, Media myths, Washington Post, Watergate myth on February 17, 2012 at 2:20 pm

Rupert Murdoch, the global media mogul beset by scandal at his British tabloids, may be the greatest menace to press freedom in world.

So says Carl Bernstein, the former Watergate reporter for the Washington Post, in an over-the-top characterization of Murdoch and what he calls Murdoch’s “gutter instincts.”

Bernstein: Murdoch a press freedom threat

Bernstein was referring to the police and parliamentary investigations into practices at Murdoch’s London tabloids, inquiries that have led to the arrests of numerous employes and the closure last summer of the Sunday News of the World.

The suspected misconduct in Britain also may have consequences for Murdoch’s News Corp. under U.S. anti-corruption laws.

Bernstein, a frequent and frankly sanctimonious critic of Murdoch since the scandals broke in London last year, declared in a recent interview on CNN:

“It’s really ironic that the greatest threat to freedom of the press in Great Britain today, and around the world today perhaps, has come from Rupert Murdoch because of his own excesses.”

What a foolish, misleading, and naive statement: The “greatest threat to freedom of the press …  around the world today perhaps” is Rupert Murdoch.

Sure, Murdoch’s hard-ball tactics and raunchy media outlets are offensive to polite company.

But the 80-year-old mogul is scarcely the world’s leading menace to press freedom. To suggest that he is is to insult the nearly 180 journalists who are in jail because of their work in Africa, Asia, and the Middle East.

The true contenders for the epithet of the world’s leading press-freedom menace are many, and include the ayatollahs in Iran.

According to the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists, Iran is the world’s leading jailer of journalists: Forty-two of the 179 journalists behind bars in late 2011 were imprisoned in Iran.

Journalists are in jail typically because their reporting in traditional or online media offended power-wielding authorities or violated censorship laws.

In Iran, CPJ points out, the “authorities seem intent on silencing any independent or critical voices.”

Bernstein’s naive remark also ignores Eritrea and China, where, respectively, 28 and 27 journalists were in jail in late 2011, according to CPJ.

The organization notes that other journalists “may languish” in Chinese jails “without coming to the notice of news organizations or advocacy groups.”

Bernstein’s comment about Murdoch likewise ignores the Castro regime in Cuba, which long has been a jailer of journalists. As many as 29 dissident journalists were arrested in 2003 in a sweeping crackdown on dissent. The last of them was released in April last year.

While CPJ counted no Cuban journalists in jail in late 2011, the organization says authorities there “continue to detain reporters and editors on a short-term basis as a form of harassment.”

Bernstein’s comment also ignored the Stalinist regime in North Korea, which ranks dead last in the annual Freedom House ranking of press freedom in the world.

Freedom House, a New York-based organization that promotes democratic governance, assesses levels of press freedom in more than 190 countries and territories on a scale of zero to 100 points. The more points, the worse the ranking.

Finland ranked first, with 10 points. The United States and Britain were rated “free,” with 17 points and 19 points, respectively.

North Korea ranked last, with 97 points.

The regime in Pyongyang “owns all media, attempts to regulate all communication, and rigorously limits the ability of North Koreans to access information,” Freedom House noted, adding that all journalists “are members of the ruling party, and all media outlets are mouthpieces for the regime.”

His recent remarks about Murdoch’s threat to press freedom were the latest of Bernstein’s over-the-top characterizations of the mogul whose media and entertainment company has holdings around the globe.

As the tabloid scandal in Britain exploded last summer, prompting the closure of the News of the World, Bernstein likened the misconduct to Watergate, the  unprecedented U.S. constitutional crisis that led to Nixon’s departure from office in disgrace in 1974.

But Watergate was sui generis. The scandal not only toppled Nixon but sent to jail 19 men associated with his presidency or his 1972 reelection campaign.

What’s more, as I discuss in my latest book, Getting It Wrong, the Watergate reporting by Bernstein and Washington Post colleague Bob Woodward was neither central to, nor decisive in, bringing down Nixon’s corrupt presidency.

WJC

Recent and related:

  4. […] to infuse drama in All the President’s Men, the book Woodward wrote with Post colleague Carl Bernstein about their Watergate […]

    Did Watergate’s ‘Deep Throat’ know he was ‘Deep Throat’? « Media Myth Alert 15 April 2012 at 11am

  5. […] The Press Club statement about Woodward’s award invokes that myth, too, asserting that “enrollment in journalism departments rose in the post-Watergate era, especially after ‘All the President’s Men’ was made into a movie.” It was based on a book by the same title, which was written by Woodward and his Post colleague, Carl Bernstein. […]

    National Press Club invokes media myths of Watergate « Media Myth Alert 30 April 2012 at 5am

  6. […] the Post’s Watergate reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, later claimed to have had a solid lead about Nixon’s taping system — a lead they did […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part Two « Media Myth Alert 18 June 2012 at 5am

  7. […] appear, either, in All the President’s Men, the book Woodward and his Post colleague, Carl Bernstein, wrote about their Watergate […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part Three « Media Myth Alert 19 June 2012 at 9am

  8. […] This installment addresses the notion that the Watergate reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein placed the reporters in grave […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part Four « Media Myth Alert 20 June 2012 at 7am

  9. […] scandal — that the dogged reporting of Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein exposed the corruption that forced Nixon’s […]

    Media myth distorts Chicago Tribune timeline of newspaper history « Media Myth Alert 20 November 2012 at 9am

  11. […] a president may soon be on the block,” the Journal states, referring to Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, the Post’s lead reporters on America’s greatest political […]

    The ‘newsroom where two reporters took down a president’? Sure it was « Media Myth Alert 2 February 2013 at 7am

  12. […] existence of the White House tapes, by the way, was not uncovered by Woodward and Bernstein. That disclosure came in July 1973, at hearings of a Senate select committee on […]

    Landmark status for WaPo building? Watergate reporting ought not be a factor « Media Myth Alert 6 February 2013 at 9am

  13. […] of a book by the Washington Post’s lead Watergate reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, who, according to CNN, were “responsible for uncovering the Watergate scandal and forcing […]

    Runup to the Oscars: ‘Politically inspired movies’ and the myth of Watergate | Media Myth Alert 22 February 2013 at 2pm

  14. […] not Woodward and his reporting sidekick Carl Bernstein, then who, or what, brought down Richard […]

    If Obama loses AP: Rush Limbaugh embraces media myths two days running | Media Myth Alert 26 February 2013 at 6pm

  15. […] far more nuanced and complex than that: Woodward and his Washington Post reporting colleague Carl Bernstein played rather modest roles in unraveling the […]

    Woodward ‘destroyed the Nixon presidency’: More dubious history from Rush Limbaugh | Media Myth Alert 1 March 2013 at 7am

  16. […] entrenched the erroneous notion that the Post was the place where Woodward and his colleague Carl Bernstein wrote the stories that exposed and ended a corrupt […]

    Good call: WaPo building no landmark | Media Myth Alert 19 September 2013 at 11am

  17. […] career in newspapering. He was the Post’s metropolitan editor during Watergate and managed Bernstein and Bob Woodward, who in 1972 and 1973 were the newspaper’s lead reporters on the unfolding […]

    Editor’s little-noted memoir offers intriguing insight about WaPo’s Watergate reporters | Media Myth Alert 21 December 2013 at 6am

  18. […] New York’s recently inaugurated mayor, fairly gushed at a news conference yesterday about Carl Bernstein, Bob Woodward, and their putative roles in unraveling the Watergate scandal, saying the duo exerted […]

    NYCity new mayor gushes over Bernstein, Woodward and their putative contributions to Watergate | Media Myth Alert 8 January 2014 at 12pm

  19. […] the President’s Men, the book in which Woodward and co-author Carl Bernstein introduced the secret source, says Woodward’s conversations with “Deep Throat” were intended […]

    ‘Deep Throat’ garage to be razed: The inaccurate historical marker should go, too | Media Myth Alert 16 June 2014 at 10am

  20. […] was striking how little new the reporters, Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward, had to say about covering a scandal that catapulted them to fame and wealth. In […]

    Watergate made boring | Media Myth Alert 31 July 2014 at 9am

  21. […] of Watergate — the mythical notion that the dogged reporting by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of the Washington Post exposed the Watergate crimes of Nixon and forced his […]

    Confronting the mythology of Watergate | Media Myth Alert 6 August 2014 at 12pm

  22. […] the story that Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, the Post’s lead Watergate reporters, still say they are most proud of was in error on […]

    Ouster of WaPo publisher prompts reference to newspaper’s mythical role in Watergate | Media Myth Alert 2 September 2014 at 10pm

  23. […] of Watergate — the mythical and simplistic notion that the reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post brought down Richard M. Nixon’s corrupt presidency — is one of […]

    The Wategate myth that offers something for everyone | Media Myth Alert 27 September 2014 at 1pm

  24. […] trope about of Watergate. It holds that the dogged reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post — guided by Woodward’s clandestine source, code-named […]

    Marking five years: The best of Media Myth Alert | Media Myth Alert 31 October 2014 at 12pm

  25. […] notion that the newspaper’s reporting — especially that of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein — uncovered the crimes that led to Nixon’s […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2014 | Media Myth Alert 29 December 2014 at 9am

  26. […] Journalism, the notion that the Post and its lead Watergate reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, “brought down” Nixon’s corrupt presidency is a fundamental misreading of history […]

    No, Politico: WaPo didn’t bring down Nixon | Media Myth Alert 27 May 2015 at 5pm

  27. […] popular narrative, which rests on the notion that dogged reporting by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of the Washington Post exposed Nixon’s criminal misconduct and forced his resignation. It […]

    The hero-journalist trope: Watergate’s go-to mythical narrative | Media Myth Alert 23 October 2015 at 6pm

  28. […] Getting It Wrong the notion that the Post and its lead Watergate reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, “brought down” Nixon’s presidency represents a fundamental misreading of history that […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2015 | Media Myth Alert 29 December 2015 at 11am

  29. […] is an important reason why Watergate’s dominant narrative has it that Bob Woodward, Carl Bernstein, and the Washington Post toppled Richard Nixon’s corrupt […]

    NYTimes invokes Watergate myth in writeup about journalists and movies | Media Myth Alert 3 January 2016 at 2pm

  30. […] prominent media myth — namely that the reporting of two of its reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, uncovered the Watergate scandal and exposed the wrongdoing that brought down Nixon’s presidency […]

    Media myths: Prominent cases of ‘fake news’ masquerading as fact | Media Myth Alert 14 December 2016 at 7pm

  31. […] 3): Watergate’s mythical dominant narrative has it that dogged reporting by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of the Washington Post exposed the crimes that toppled Richard Nixon’s corrupt presidency in […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2016 | Media Myth Alert 28 December 2016 at 6am

  32. […] myth of Watergate — the notion that dogged reporting by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt presidency — pops up […]

    The heroic-journalist myth of Watergate and its applications | Media Myth Alert 28 April 2017 at 3pm

  33. […] trope of Watergate, the ever-engaging myth that the dogged reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt […]

    Watergate shows that ‘journalists can, under right circumstances, topple a presidency’: What a myth | Media Myth Alert 1 May 2017 at 8am

  34. […] the mythical go-to narrative that the Post and its intrepid reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, unearthed the incriminating evidence that forced Nixon to resign in disgrace in August […]

    WaPo’s ‘myths about Watergate’ article ignores the scandal’s best-known mythical narrative | Media Myth Alert 22 May 2017 at 3pm

  35. […] may seem picky to dispute claims that the Watergate reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein “exposed the coverup” the Nixon administration put in place to deflect […]

    Say, CJR: Never hurts to check your archives | Media Myth Alert 17 September 2018 at 7am

  36. […] narrative of Watergate, the ever-enticing notion that dogged reporting by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post uncovered evidence that brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt […]

    Even in a pandemic, media myths play on | Media Myth Alert 26 April 2020 at 10am

  37. […] referred to Woodward and his Watergate reporting partner at the Washington Post, Carl Bernstein, and declared they had “brought down the presidency of Richard […]

    Woodward’s latest Trump book prompts myth-telling about Watergate | Media Myth Alert 22 September 2020 at 7pm

  38. […] New York Post stated that Woodward and his Watergate reporting partner at the Washington Post, Carl Bernstein, had together “brought down the presidency of Richard […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2020 | Media Myth Alert 30 December 2020 at 9pm

  39. […] appraisal, however inelegant, is on-target. He and Bernstein did not topple […]

    Once-prominent E&P tells media myths about Murrow, Watergate | Media Myth Alert 18 September 2021 at 10am

  40. […] which took place nearly 50 years ago — has it that dogged reporting by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of the Washington Post uncovered the crimes that brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2021 | Media Myth Alert 28 December 2021 at 9am

  41. […] Myth Alert is only faintly interested in a memoir by Bernstein, a bloviating commentator for CNN nowadays. It’s the review’s unsourced passage, […]

    WaPo review indulges in myth, claims Bernstein’s ‘work brought down a president’ | Media Myth Alert 16 January 2022 at 10am

  42. […] their dogged reporting of the Watergate scandal, Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein uncovered the crimes that forced Richard Nixon to resign the presidency in August […]

    Watergate at 50: Why the ‘heroic-journalist’ myth still defines the scandal | Media Myth Alert 16 June 2022 at 8am

  43. […] Post’s entry included an article by Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward that proved […]

    Watergate footnote: WaPo’s Pulitzer-winning entry included a false story | Media Myth Alert 21 August 2022 at 6pm

  44. […] Margaret Sullivan praises the newspaper’s Watergate reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, for having “lit the kindling” that set off investigations that brought down Richard […]

    They ‘lit the kindling’: New memoir exaggerates Woodward, Bernstein’s agenda-setting effect in Watergate | Media Myth Alert 25 October 2022 at 7am

  45. […] myth has it that Bernstein and his Post colleague, Bob Woodward, uncovered in their tireless reporting evidence that forced […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2022 | Media Myth Alert 27 December 2022 at 7am

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: