W. Joseph Campbell

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM

In Cinematic treatments, Debunking, Newspapers, Reviews, Washington Post, Watergate myth on February 27, 2011 at 8:26 am

(Oscars.org)

Today’s Washington Post offers an insightful commentary about movies that won best-picture Oscars despite having taken liberties with historical truth.

The commentary notes that this year’s favorite for best picture, The King’s Speech, “won’t win any awards for historical accuracy.

“King George VI didn’t really stammer that badly, we’ve been told. Critics have also pointed out that Winston Churchill didn’t actually think it necessary for the king’s brother, Edward VIII, to abdicate the throne before marrying a divorced woman. We’ve also learned that Churchill was not nearly as fat as Timothy Spall portrays him … and that King George was far too plain and short to be played by the tall, handsome Colin Firth.”

What’s more, the Post notes:

“The Oscar voters have often favored historically faulty movies, with the inaccuracies ranging from minor details to outright fiction. In ‘Patton,’ 1970’s Best Picture, Axis and Allied powers fought each other in the same kind of tanks — American ones, manufactured after the war. ‘Braveheart’ in 1995 put Mel Gibson in a kilt, even though his character, William Wallace, was a lowland Scot (and only highlanders wore kilts).”

Good stuff.

Surely it’s not churlish to call out the Post for failing to include All the President’s Men in the discussion about historical inaccuracy in movie-making — even if All the President’s Men (or ATPM) didn’t win the best picture Oscar for the year in which it was released.

Rocky did.

All the President’s Men of course was a 1976 film about the Washington Post and its Watergate investigation, starring those dogged reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein. It won four Oscars, including best supporting actor, for Jason Robards’ role as the Post executive editor, Ben Bradlee.

The movie — which was based on Woodward and Bernstein’s 1974 book by the same title — distorted, stretched, and otherwise toyed with historical accuracy in several ways, namely:

  • It embraced and solidified the mythical heroic-journalist interpretation of Watergate.
  • It minimized, even denigrated, the decisive contributions of investigative agencies in unraveling the crimes of Watergate.
  • It depicted Woodward and Bernstein as facing dangers far greater than they really encountered.
  • It introduced into the vernacular the made-up line, “follow the money,” which many people believe was advice crucial to uncovering the scandal.

Let’s examine those points in turn.

As I discuss in my latest book, Getting It Wrong, the cinematic version of All the President’s Men promoted the misleading interpretation that Woodward and Bernstein’s reporting was decisive in uncovering the crimes of Watergate and forcing the resignation of President Richard Nixon.

I write in Getting It Wrong:

“All the President’s Men allows no other interpretation: It was the work Woodward and Bernstein that set in motion far-reaching effects that brought about the first-ever resignation of a U.S. president.”

I also note:

“To an extent far greater than the book, the cinematic version of All the President’s Men placed Woodward and Bernstein at the center of Watergate’s unraveling while denigrating the efforts of investigative agencies such as the FBI. The effect was to solidify and elevate the heroic-journalist myth, giving it dramatic power, and sustaining it in the collective memory.”

To roll up a scandal of the dimensions of Watergate, I point out in Getting It Wrong, “required the collective if not always the coordinated forces of special prosecutors, federal judges, both houses of Congress, the Supreme Court, as well as the Justice Department and the FBI.

“Even then,” I add, “Nixon likely would have served out his term if not for the audiotape recordings he secretly made of most conversations in the Oval Office of the White House. Only when compelled by the Supreme Court did Nixon surrender those recordings, which captured him” plotting to cover up the signal crime of Watergate — the 1972 break-in at headquarters of the Democratic National Committee.

The cinematic version of All the President’s Men includes few references to subpoena-wielding agencies and congressional panels that broke open the scandal.

In addition, the movie excessively dramatizes the risks and hazards to which Woodward and Bernstein were exposed in their Watergate reporting.

In a  scene near the close of the movie, Woodward’s shadowy, high-level source “Deep Throat” — superbly played by Hal Holbrook — says the reporters’ “lives are in danger.”

The warning, which injected drama into the movie’s sometimes-leaden pacing, also was mentioned in All the President’s Men the book.

But it was fairly quickly recognized to have been a false alarm.

For a while, Woodward, Bernstein, and senior Post editors took precautions to avoid what they suspected was electronic surveillance. But as Woodward recounted in his book The Secret Man, such measures “soon seemed melodramatic and unnecessary.

“We never found any evidence that our phones were tapped or that anyone’s life was in danger,” Woodward added.

The Holbrook/”Deep Throat” character in All the President’s Men pressed into the vernacular what may be Watergate’s most famous line — “follow the money.”

The line does not appear in Woodward and Bernstein’s book. Nor was it spoken in real life by the stealthy “Deep Throat,” whose identity was kept secret for more than 30 years. (In 2005, the former second-ranking official at the FBI, W. Mark Felt, disclosed that he had been Woodward’s high-level source.)

“Follow the money” was worked into the script of All the President’s Men by the screenwriter, William Goldman.

The Holbrook/”Deep Throat” character delivered the line  with such quiet authority that it’s not difficult to understand how “follow the money” crossed from the silver  screen to the vernacular, how the phrase has been widely embraced not only as plausible but understood as guidance that had been invaluable.

As I’ve noted, however, Watergate was far more complex than a matter of identifying, pursuing, and describing a money trail.

The best cinematic antidote to All the President’s Men has to be the 1999 spoof Dick, which includes an amusing if over-the-top skewering of Woodward and Bernstein as klutzy, antagonistic, and ultimately very lucky.

Dick the movie won no Oscars. But it’s great fun, and deserves to be seen more widely than it was in 1999.

WJC

Recent and related:

  1. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM (via Media Myth Alert) Posted on 28 February, 2011 by Jarle Petterson Today’s [Sunday, Calculable note] Washington Post offers an insightful commentary about movies that won best-picture Oscars despite having taken liberties with historical truth. The commentary notes that this year’s favorite for best picture, The King’s Speech, “won’t win any awards for historical accuracy. “King George VI didn’t really stammer that badly, we’ve been told. Criti … Read More […]

    WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM (via Media Myth Alert) | The Calculable 28 February 2011 at 1am

  2. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    ‘Kill the Irishman’: Glamorizing ’70s Cleveland underworld? « Media Myth Alert 2 March 2011 at 7am

  3. […] that the Post never used the phrase in its articles or editorials about […]

    ‘Sigue el dinero’: That made-up Watergate line gets around « Media Myth Alert 5 March 2011 at 7am

  4. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    Exaggerating Cleveland as ’70s Belfast on the lake « Media Myth Alert 7 March 2011 at 7am

  5. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    Pumping up Watergate’s heroic-journalist myth « Media Myth Alert 10 March 2011 at 8am

  6. […] noted at Media Myth Alert, “follow the money” was advice written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the 1976 cinematic version of the book by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein about their Watergate […]

    Fact-checking Watergate advice that ‘worked’ « Media Myth Alert 11 March 2011 at 8am

  7. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    Mythmaking in Moscow: Biden says WaPo brought down Nixon « Media Myth Alert 12 March 2011 at 7am

  8. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    Of media myths and false lessons abroad: Biden’s Moscow gaffe « Media Myth Alert 14 March 2011 at 7am

  9. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    WaPo ‘broke the Watergate scandal’? No way « Media Myth Alert 17 March 2011 at 7am

  10. […] in weeks ahead to “follow the money.” After all, the 35th anniversary of the release of All the President’s Men falls next […]

    ‘Follow the money,’ again and again « Media Myth Alert 21 March 2011 at 7am

  11. […] made journalism seem sexy, vital, urgent. They were, after all, subjects of a major motion picture, All the President’s Men, which was based on their best-selling book by the same […]

    Inspirations to journalists: Woodward, Bernstein — and Gaga? « Media Myth Alert 9 April 2011 at 7am

  12. […] was a line written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the 1976 motion picture that dramatized the Watergate reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein […]

    Always ‘follow the money’ — even if it’s made up « Media Myth Alert 11 April 2011 at 10am

  13. […] — and the celebrity cult of Watergate — were solidified by the cinematic version of All the President‘s Men, Woodward and Bernstein’s book about their Watergate […]

    Something exaggerated in hero-worship of Woodward « Media Myth Alert 21 April 2011 at 9am

  14. […] I discuss in Getting It Wrong, my media-mythbusting book that came out last year, All the President’s Men placed the characters of Woodward and Bernstein squarely if inappropriately “at the center of […]

    That’s rich: Woodward bemoans celebrity journalism « Media Myth Alert 24 April 2011 at 11am

  15. […] of course, played Woodward in the motion picture, All the President’s Men, which was released 35 years ago this […]

    Woodward, ‘tombeur de Nixon’ « Media Myth Alert 25 April 2011 at 7am

  16. […] famous line was written into the cinematic version of All the President’s Men, which came out 35 years ago last […]

    A ‘follow the money’ hat trick « Media Myth Alert 14 May 2011 at 9am

  17. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    Every good historian a mythbuster « Media Myth Alert 27 May 2011 at 6am

  18. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    That was quick: Crummy Cleveland mob pic now out on DVD « Media Myth Alert 16 June 2011 at 1pm

  19. […] source cultivated by Bob Woodward of the Washington Post, was written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the movie about the work of Woodward and his Post colleague, Carl Bernstein. “Follow the […]

    Those delicious but phony quotes ‘that refuse to die’ « Media Myth Alert 25 June 2011 at 10am

  21. […] All the President’s Men, the 1976 cinematic version of the book by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein about their Watergate reporting for the Washington Post, and […]

    ‘Sneakily patriotic’ movies that promote media myths « Media Myth Alert 1 July 2011 at 7am

  22. […] Hoffman, the movie stars who played Washington Post reporters Woodward and Bernstein in the film All the President’s Men. “Armed only with a pen,” Unger wrote, “they saved the country from […]

    The journos who saved us « Media Myth Alert 5 July 2011 at 12pm

  23. […] Men was Woodward and Bernstein’s 1974 book about their Watergate reporting. The book’s cinematic version came out in 1976 and helped solidify the mythical notion that the Post brought down […]

    Imprecise, overwrought Watergate analogies emerge in Murdoch scandal « Media Myth Alert 17 July 2011 at 3am

  24. […] in All the President’s Men, the cinematic version of Woodward and Bernstein’s book. The movie was released to much fanfare in April 1976, 20 months after Nixon resigned the presidency for his […]

    An outbreak of ‘follow the money,’ that phony Watergate line « Media Myth Alert 23 July 2011 at 7am

  25. […] presented Watergate’s most famous invented line, “follow the money,” as if it were genuine. The phrase was in fact written into the screenplay of the Watergate movie, All the President’s Men. […]

    More media myths from CounterPunch « Media Myth Alert 24 July 2011 at 8am

  26. […] images projected on the screen: “Follow the money” was written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the cinematic version of the Watergate book by Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl […]

    The Fin Times and the ‘mantra’ of Watergate « Media Myth Alert 28 July 2011 at 7am

  27. […] the money” was written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the 1976 movie based on Woodward and Bernstein’s […]

    India high court order invokes phony Watergate line « Media Myth Alert 2 August 2011 at 9am

  28. […] phrase exists only in the movies — in the cinematic version of All the President’s Men, which came out in April […]

    Fox News misremembers Watergate and ‘follow the money’ « Media Myth Alert 16 August 2011 at 9am

  29. […] Another reason that Watergate’s dominant narrative focuses so squarely on Woodward, Bernstein, and the Washington Post is, I said, the cinematic version of the reporters’ book, All the President’s Men. […]

    Talking media myths on ‘Community Voices’ « Media Myth Alert 3 September 2011 at 3pm

  30. […] and Bernstein’s book about their reporting of the unfolding Watergate scandal; the popular cinematic version of their book, All the President’s Men, and the years-long guessing game about the identity […]

    A ‘certain American paper brought down a certain president’ « Media Myth Alert 29 September 2011 at 4am

  31. […] “follow the money” was written into the screenplay of the cinematic version of All the President’s Men; the line was memorably uttered not by Felt, the real-life “Deep Throat,” but by Hal […]

    Made-up Watergate line, ‘follow the money,’ crosses into the news « Media Myth Alert 6 October 2011 at 4am

  32. […] source code-named “Deep Throat.” The advice supposedly was offered to Bob Woodward, a Washington Post reporter covering […]

    ‘Deep Throat’ didn’t say ‘follow the money’; nor was he vital in Watergate « Media Myth Alert 13 October 2011 at 12am

  33. […] the money” was genuine and vital advice offered by the stealthy, high-level source whom the Post code-named “Deep […]

    ‘Follow the money’ and the power of cinema « Media Myth Alert 8 January 2012 at 9am

  34. […] The persistence of that misreading narrative, I said, can be traced to All the President’s Men, Woodward and Bernstein’s 1974 book about their Watergate reporting, and especially to the 1976 movie by the same title. […]

    ‘Getting It Wrong’ goes on ‘One Hour of Hope’ « Media Myth Alert 10 January 2012 at 12pm

  35. […] Post quoted one of the anonymous officials as saying: “She was fighting to the death. She did not […]

    Liz Trotta mangles Jessica Lynch ‘fairy tale’ « Media Myth Alert 20 February 2012 at 10am

  36. […] beyond impression and anecdote, what supports the claim that Watergate reporting — or All the President’s Men — was a powerful stimulant for career-seeking in […]

    Assessing the propellant effect: Was Watergate a powerful stimulant to journalism? « Media Myth Alert 10 March 2012 at 4am

  37. […] book, a months-long best-seller, had been written with the movies in mind; the cinematic version of All the President’s Men came out in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford as Woodward and […]

    Woodward and Bernstein: The ‘only superstars newspapers ever produced’? « Media Myth Alert 16 April 2012 at 5am

  38. […] that Watergate reporting — and the cinema’s depiction of the Post’s coverage in All the President’s Men – made the field seem so alluring  that enrollments in college journalism programs surged as […]

    National Press Club invokes media myths of Watergate « Media Myth Alert 30 April 2012 at 5am

  39. […] impression was deepened in the cinematic version of All the President’s Men, which was released to great fanfare and rave reviews in April […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part One « Media Myth Alert 17 June 2012 at 6am

  40. […] the money” was written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the cinematic adaptation of Woodward and Bernstein’s […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part Three « Media Myth Alert 19 June 2012 at 9am

  41. […] they would surely have reflected heightened interest in careers in the profession. If Watergate and All the President’s Men inspired broad interest in careers in journalism, evidence of the stimulus should be apparent in […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part Five « Media Myth Alert 21 June 2012 at 6am

  43. […] especially “significant,” historically. (The newsroom certainly was made famous in All the President’s Men,  the cinematic version of Woodward and Bernstein’s book about their Watergate reporting. A […]

    Landmark status for WaPo building? Watergate reporting ought not be a factor « Media Myth Alert 6 February 2013 at 9am

  44. […] runup to the Academy Awards ceremony brings inevitable bursts of nostalgia — as well as the almost-predictable appearance […]

    Runup to the Oscars: ‘Politically inspired movies’ and the myth of Watergate | Media Myth Alert 22 February 2013 at 2pm

  45. […] the historical inaccuracy the marker ought to […]

    Good call: WaPo building no landmark | Media Myth Alert 19 September 2013 at 11am

  46. […] outcome. Their contributions — while glamorized in the cinematic version of their book, All the President’s Men — were marginal in forcing Nixon’s […]

    WaPo now embracing the dominant myth of Watergate? | Media Myth Alert 22 July 2014 at 8pm

  47. […] myth — and the celebrity cult of Watergate — were solidified by the film adaptation of All the President‘s Men, Woodward and Bernstein’s book about their Watergate reporting. I note in Getting It Wrong that […]

    Confronting the mythology of Watergate | Media Myth Alert 6 August 2014 at 12pm

  48. […] and Bernstein’s best-selling book about their Watergate reporting; the popularity of the cinematic version of their book, and the years-long speculation about the identity of Woodward’s well-placed […]

    NYTimes Mag and the heroic-journalist myth of Watergate | Media Myth Alert 18 September 2014 at 3pm

  49. […] in Rather’s role, Truth has invited comparisons — not all of them favorable — to All the President’s Men, the 1976 film in which Redford played Woodward of the […]

    The hero-journalist trope: Watergate’s go-to mythical narrative | Media Myth Alert 23 October 2015 at 6pm

  51. […] and Bernstein’s Watergate reporting for the Post had no such effect, however much the cinematic version of their book, All the President’s Men, encouraged that notion. As I noted in my 2010 book, […]

    NYTimes invokes Watergate myth in writeup about journalists and movies | Media Myth Alert 3 January 2016 at 2pm

  52. […] it was released 40 years ago this month, the cinematic version of the Watergate book  All the President’s Men was the topic of soaring […]

    Gushing about ‘All the President’s Men,’ the movie — and ignoring the myths it propelled | Media Myth Alert 18 April 2016 at 6am

  53. […] the money” was born of dramatic license, a line written into the screenplay of All the President’s Men, the cinematic version of Woodward and Bernstein’s eponymous book about their Watergate […]

    WaPo’s ‘myths about Watergate’ article ignores the scandal’s best-known mythical narrative | Media Myth Alert 22 May 2017 at 3pm

  54. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    ‘Mark Felt’ biopic worse than its negative reviews | Media Myth Alert 14 October 2017 at 1pm

  55. […] WaPo on ‘historically faulty’ films: Ignoring ATPM […]

    ‘The Post’: Bad history = bad movie | Media Myth Alert 2 January 2018 at 11am

  56. […] complaints are fair enough, when accurate. Plenty of American history has been distorted by the […]

    ‘Chappaquiddick,’ the movie: Muddled character study | Media Myth Alert 9 April 2018 at 9am

  57. […] presented a rundown about the top films with a journalism theme. Atop the critic’s list was All the President’s Men, the cinematic adaptation of Woodward and Bernstein’s eponymous, best-selling […]

    Even in a pandemic, media myths play on | Media Myth Alert 26 April 2020 at 10am

  58. […] articles recalled Holbrook’s advice in the film All the President’s Men to “follow the money” as if it were key to unraveling the scandal that culminated in […]

    Hal Holbrook, ‘follow the money,’ and Watergate’s distorted history | Media Myth Alert 3 February 2021 at 8am

  59. […] movie All the President’s Men certainly leaves the impression Nixon was dethroned by journalism, given its focus on the […]

    Watergate myth, extravagant version: Nixon was ‘dethroned entirely’ by press | Media Myth Alert 24 April 2021 at 7am

  60. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein didn't bring down a president in Watergate – but the myth that they did lives on - The TechTab 14 June 2022 at 2pm

  61. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein did not carry down a president in Watergate – however the fantasy that they did lives on | Liliana News 14 June 2022 at 2pm

  62. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein didn’t bring down a president in Watergate – but the myth that they did lives on – Advance Press Net 14 June 2022 at 3pm

  63. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein didn't bring down a president in Watergate – but the myth that they did lives on - Ramandwisse 14 June 2022 at 11pm

  64. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein didn’t bring down a president – but the myth that they did lives on - JARA News 15 June 2022 at 3pm

  65. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, disregarding the operate of prosecutors and the […]

    50 a very long time of Watergate: Woodward and Bernstein didn't deliver down a president – however the fantasy that they did life on - Global Eco Stores 15 June 2022 at 4pm

  66. […] so than the book, the cinematic adaptation of All the President’s Men placed Woodward and Bernstein at the decisive center of Watergate’s unraveling. The movie, which […]

    Watergate at 50: Why the ‘heroic-journalist’ myth still defines the scandal | Media Myth Alert 16 June 2022 at 8am

  67. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein didn’t bring down a president in Watergate – but the myth that they did lives on | New Pittsburgh Courier 16 June 2022 at 9am

  68. […] in April 1976 and starred Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman, was relentlessly media-centric, ignoring the work of prosecutors and the […]

    Woodward and Bernstein didn’t bring down a president in Watergate – but the myth that they did lives on - George Onin Lending Mortgage Services 19 June 2022 at 2pm

Comments are closed.