W. Joseph Campbell

, , , , , , , ,

Woah, WaPo: Mythmaking in the movies

In Cinematic treatments, Debunking, Jessica Lynch, Media myths, Washington Post, Watergate myth on December 8, 2010 at 12:09 pm

I was traveling last week and only recently caught up with the eye-opening recent editorial in the Washington Post that took to task the makers of Fair Game, a just-released movie about the Valerie Plame-CIA leak affair, which stirred a lot of misplaced fury seven years ago.

The Post editorial is eye-opening in a revealing way, describing Fair Game as “full of distortions–not to mention outright inventions.”

Even more revealing–and pertinent to Media Myth Alert–was this observation:

“Hollywood has a habit of making movies about historical events without regard for the truth; ‘Fair Game’ is just one more example. But the film’s reception illustrates a more troubling trend of political debates in Washington in which established facts are willfully ignored.”

That’s akin to the point I make in my latest book, Getting It Wrong, about how cinema can propel and solidify media-driven myths.

On that point, I write in Getting It Wrong:

“High-quality cinematic treatments are powerful agents of media myth-making, and can enhance a myth’s durability.

“Untold millions of Americans born after 1954 were introduced to the Murrow-McCarthy confrontation through Good Night, and Good Luck, a critically acclaimed film released in 2005 that cleverly promoted the myth that Murrow stood up to McCarthy when no one else would or could.”

Good Night, and Good Luck is but one example of cinema’s mythmaking capacity.

Not surprisingly, comments made online about the Post editorial were largely critical. Said one: “You just reminded me why I stopped reading the Washington Post editorials and began subscribing to the New York Times.”

Said another: “This editorial proves the thesis that The Post is willing to go to any length to suck up to the power elite in order to maintain access to the same.”

And another, more perceptive comment read:

“The myth-making in ‘Fair Game’ is no more or less egregious than it was in ‘All the President’s Men.’ Hollywood loves simplistic story lines (which is why the likes of John Sirica and Archibald Cox were nowhere to be found in ‘ATPM’).”

Now that’s an excellent point.

As I note in Getting It Wrong:

“The 1976 cinematic version of All the President’s Men solidified the notion that young, diligent reporters for the Washington Post brought down President Richard Nixon. That myth of Watergate may be stronger than ever, given that All the President’s Men is the first and perhaps only extended exposure many people have to the complex scandal that was Watergate.

“Thanks in part to Hollywood, the heroic-journalist myth of Watergate has become the most familiar and readily accessible explanation about why Nixon left office in disgrace.”

Indeed, All the President’s Men has been a significant contributor to the misleading yet dominant popular narrative of Watergate, that the reporting of Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein uncovered evidence that forced Nixon’s resignation. The movie focuses on the reporters and their work, ignoring the more significant contributions of Sirica, a federal judge, and Cox, a special prosecutor, in unraveling the Watergate scandal.

As bold as it may have been, the Post editorial about Hollywood and Fair Game might have gone farther and ruminated about the effects of All the President’s Men.  Still, it was a telling and impressive commentary.

I not infrequently take the Post to task at Media Myth Alert, usually for its unwillingness to confront its singular role in thrusting the Jessica Lynch case into the public domain. The Post, I’ve argued, ought to disclose the sources for its electrifying but bogus story about Lynch’s supposed battlefield heroics in Iraq.

The newspaper’s unwillingness to do so has allowed the false popular narrative that the Pentagon concocted the story to emerge and become dominant. Even one of the reporters on the Lynch story has said, “Our sources for that story were not Pentagon sources.”

But for its clear-eyed editorial about Fair Game, the Post deserves a tip of the chapeau.

WJC

Recent and related:

  1. […] time to time, the Washington Post has sought to dismiss the notion that its Watergate reporting was decisive in bringing down the […]

    ‘You might bring down a government’: Sure, that happens « Media Myth Alert 11 December 2010 at 7am

  2. […] Woah, WaPo: Mythmaking in the movies […]

    ‘Follow the tenspot’ « Media Myth Alert 12 December 2010 at 10am

  3. […] the President’s Men, the most-seen movie about the Watergate scandal, may be released on Blu-ray early next year, according to a post […]

    Mythmaking on Blu-ray? « Media Myth Alert 20 December 2010 at 11am

  4. […] put, that’s erroneous. Erroneous to say the Post “uncovered […]

    ‘The newspaper that uncovered Watergate’? « Media Myth Alert 23 December 2010 at 12pm

  6. […] moment” in investigative journalism? Well, that had to be the Watergate reporting of the Washington Post in the early […]

    The ‘defining moment’ in investigative journalism? Wasn’t Watergate « Media Myth Alert 8 January 2011 at 9am

  7. […] notion that the Post and its reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt […]

    The elusive ‘defining moment’ in investigative journalism « Media Myth Alert 9 January 2011 at 9am

  10. […] research has shown that Woodward, Bernstein, and the cinematic treatment of All the President’s Men did not prompt enrollments to climb at journalism and mass […]

    Talking ethics and the ‘golden days’ of Watergate « Media Myth Alert 19 January 2011 at 8am

  11. […] William Goldman has taken credit for writing “follow the  money” into the script of All the President’s Men, which came out in 1976, less than two years after Watergate reached a climax with the resignation […]

    ‘Follow the money’: Why the made-up Watergate line endures « Media Myth Alert 8 February 2011 at 10am

  12. […] Goldman has taken credit for writing the line into the script of All the President’s Men, the cinematic version of Woodward and Carl Bernstein’s book about their Watergate […]

    ‘Follow the money’ and the ‘new blue bloods’ in Parliament « Media Myth Alert 12 February 2011 at 10am

  13. […] All the President’s Men is entertaining and has help up impressively well in the 35 years since its release. The movie purports to recount tell the ingenuity and persistence of Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein in investigating the scandal that ultimately brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt presidency. […]

    A history lesson not to miss? No, but it is entertaining « Media Myth Alert 18 February 2011 at 9am

  16. […] William Goldman has taken credit for writing “follow the  money” into the script of All the President’s Men, which came out in April 1976 — 20 months after Watergate reached a denouement with the […]

    Fact-checking Watergate advice that ‘worked’ « Media Myth Alert 11 March 2011 at 8am

  17. […] moment” in investigative journalism? Well, that had to be the Watergate reporting of the Washington Post in the early 1970s. So says Britain’s serious-minded Financial Times in […]

    The ‘defining moment’ in investigative journalism wasn’t Watergate » Article » OWNI.eu, Digital Journalism 17 March 2011 at 12pm

  19. […] Redford played the Woodward character in All the President’s Men. […]

    Something exaggerated in hero-worship of Woodward « Media Myth Alert 21 April 2011 at 9am

  20. […] the other night at a panel in Austin, Texas, that was convened to mark the 35th anniversary of All the President’s Men, the motion picture about the Watergate reporting of Woodward and his Post colleague, Carl […]

    That’s rich: Woodward bemoans celebrity journalism « Media Myth Alert 24 April 2011 at 11am

  21. […] more powerful reason is to be found in the cinematic adaptation of All the President’s Men, Woodward and Bernstein’s book about their Watergate […]

    Every good historian a mythbuster « Media Myth Alert 27 May 2011 at 6am

  22. […] Holbrook advised the Woodward character, played by Robert Redford, to “follow the money” — and did so with such quiet assurance and insistence that it sure seemed as if the guidance were vital to rolling up Watergate. […]

    Commodity markets and Watergate’s most famous made-up line « Media Myth Alert 15 June 2011 at 7am

  25. […] myth-promoting movies push the extravagant notion that the news media are, or were, powerful and decisive forces in […]

    ‘Sneakily patriotic’ movies that promote media myths « Media Myth Alert 1 July 2011 at 7am

  26. […] the popular consciousness was an outstanding performance turned in by actor Hal Holbrook in the cinematic version of All the President’s […]

    An outbreak of ‘follow the money,’ that phony Watergate line « Media Myth Alert 23 July 2011 at 7am

  27. […] the money” into the vernacular was the marvelous performance of actor Hal Holbrook in the cinematic version of All the President’s […]

    The Fin Times and the ‘mantra’ of Watergate « Media Myth Alert 28 July 2011 at 7am

  28. […] “Deep Throat” character was played in All the President’s Men by the actor Hal Holbrook, who turned in a marvelous […]

    India high court order invokes phony Watergate line « Media Myth Alert 2 August 2011 at 9am

  29. […] narrative focuses so squarely on Woodward, Bernstein, and the Washington Post is, I said, the cinematic version of the reporters’ book, All the President’s […]

    Talking media myths on ‘Community Voices’ « Media Myth Alert 3 September 2011 at 3pm

  30. […] line was spoke by Hal Holbrook, the actor who played “Deep Throat” in All the President’s Men. (The real “Deep Throat” was self-revealed in 2005 to have been W. Mark Felt, a senior […]

    ‘Follow the money’ and the power of cinema « Media Myth Alert 8 January 2012 at 9am

  31. […] impression was deepened in the cinematic version of All the President’s Men, which was released to great fanfare and rave reviews in April […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part One « Media Myth Alert 17 June 2012 at 6am

  32. […] in All the President’s Men turned in a marvelous performance as a twitchy, conflicted, chain-smoking “Deep Throat.” […]

    The media myths of Watergate: Part Three « Media Myth Alert 19 June 2012 at 9am

  37. […] cinematic treatment of All the President’s Men was released in April 1976 to mostly rave reviews. The New York Times critic wrote that “not […]

    NYTimes Mag and the heroic-journalist myth of Watergate | Media Myth Alert 18 September 2014 at 3pm

  40. […] put, that’s erroneous. Erroneous to say the Post “uncovered […]

    ‘The newspaper that uncovered Watergate’? | Media Myth Alert 6 May 2018 at 1pm

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: