W. Joseph Campbell

, , , , , , , , , , , ,

The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’

In 1897, Anniversaries, Debunking, Furnish the war, Media myths, Newspapers, Spanish-American War, Yellow Journalism on January 13, 2011 at 7:31 am

Remington, Davis in Cuba for Hearst

Had it occurred, the legendary but improbable exchange of telegrams between William Randolph Hearst and the artist Frederic Remington–in which Hearst supposedly vowed to “furnish the war” with Spain–would have taken place in mid-January 1897.

The uncertainty as to exactly when the purported exchange occurred is one of many signals the tale is apocryphal, a media-driven myth.

As I discuss in my media-mythbusting book, Getting It Wrong, the Remington-Hearst anecdote is “perhaps the hardiest myth in American journalism.”

It lives on in part because it is a pithy and delicious tale. It corresponds well to the image of Hearst the war-monger, the unscrupulous newspaper published who fomented the Spanish-American War in 1898.

As I point out in the first chapter of Getting It Wrong, the Remington-Hearst tale is often retold “despite a nearly complete absence of supporting documentation. It lives on even though telegrams supposedly exchanged by Remington and Hearst have never turned up. It lives on even though Hearst denied ever sending such a message.”

Moreover, I write:

The anecdote “lives on despite an irreconcilable internal inconsistency: It would have been absurd for Hearst to vow to ‘furnish the war’ because war—specifically, the Cuban rebellion against Spain’s colonial rule—was the very reason Hearst sent Remington to Cuba in the first place.”

The sole original source for the “furnish the war” quotation was On the Great Highway, a slim volume of reminiscences that came out in 1901. The author was James Creelman, a portly, cigar-chomping journalist prone to pomposity and exaggeration.

Creelman did not explain in On the Great Highway how or where he learned about the purported Remingt0n-Hearst exchange. Creelman–who was in Madrid at the time Remington was in Cuba–recounted the anecdote a not as a rebuke but as a compliment to Hearst and the activist “yellow journalism” he had pioneered in New York City.

Nor did Creelman say exactly when the presumed exchange took place, writing only that it was “some time before the destruction of the battleship Maine in the harbor of Havana” in mid-February 1898. The only time Remington was in Cuba before the explosion that destroyed the Maine was in January 1897.

Creelman: Sole source

Remington, an accomplished artist of the American West, went to Cuba in 1897 to draw sketches of scenes of the uprising against Spanish rule. He traveled with Richard Harding Davis, who then was burnishing a reputation as one of American journalism’s leading correspondents.

Hearst recruited Remington and Davis for a month, and the plan was for them to reach a force of Cuban rebels under the command of Máximo Gómez.

But Remington and Davis never reached the rebels. What’s more, they proved to be an oddly matched team. In Matanzas on January 15, 1897, they parted ways. Remington returned to Havana and the next day boarded a steamship bound for New York.

Legend has it that before leaving Havana, Remington sent Hearst a telegram that supposedly said:

“Everything is quiet. There will be no war. I wish to return.”

Hearst purportedly cabled Remington in reply:

“Please remain. You furnish the pictures, and I’ll furnish the war.”

Had it occurred, the exchange would have taken place late on January 15, 1897, or early on January 16, 1897.

Remington disregarded Hearst’s purported instructions to “remain” in Cuba. The artist was one of seven passengers aboard the Seneca when it sailed from Havana on January 16, 1897. The steamer reached New York four days later and soon afterward, Hearst’s New York Journal began publishing Remington’s sketches drawn in Cuba.

“The work was given prominent display,” I note in Getting It Wrong. Headlines in the Journal hailed Remington as a “gifted artist”–hardly the sort of accolade Hearst would have extended to someone in his employ who had brazenly disregarded instructions to remain on the scene.

That’s further reason for doubting that Hearst ever sent a telegram vowing to “furnish the war.”

And yet another reason is that Spanish censors, who controlled all incoming and outgoing cable traffic in Havana, surely would have intercepted Hearst’s inflammatory message, had it been sent. It’s highly improbable that cables such as those attributed to Hearst and Remington would have flowed readily between New York and Havana.

Additionally, the correspondence of Davis gives lie to the anecdote.

Davis wrote frequently to his family, especially to his mother, Rebecca Harding Davis. His letters make clear that  Remington did not leave because they found “everything is quiet” in Cuba.

In fact, Davis wrote on the day he and Remington parted ways:

“There is war here and no mistake.”

His correspondence offered detailed descriptions of what he called the grim process “of extermination and ruin” in Cuba.

More important, Davis’ letters make clear that Remington left for home not on the pretext that “everything is quiet,” but because Davis wanted him to go.

“I am as relieved at getting old Remington to go as though I had won $5000,” Davis wrote to his mother on January 15, 1897. “He was a splendid fellow but a perfect kid and had to be humored and petted all the time.”

Davis added that he “was very glad” Remington left “for he kept me back all the time and I can do twice as much in half the time.”

I note in Getting It Wrong that the Remington-Hearst tale was “Creelman’s singular contribution to American journalism.” The anecdote has proven to have timeless appeal, in part because it promotes what I call “the improbable notion the media are powerful and dangerous forces, so powerful they can even bring on a war.”

WJC

Recent and related:

  1. […] and far-flung newsgathering ventures. (Hearst spent lavishly to gather the news; in 1897, he paid Richard Harding Davis the contemporary equivalent of $50,000 to report from Cuba for a month on the uprising against […]

    NYTimes practices ‘yellow journalism’? How so? « Media Myth Alert 14 January 2011 at 8am

  2. […] My opinion? Such ruminations are glib, superficial and, in reference to Cronkite, the stuff of media myth. […]

    Cronkite’s view on Vietnam ‘changed course of history’ But how? « Media Myth Alert 17 January 2011 at 7am

  3. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    Have a look: New trailer for ‘Getting It Wrong’ « Media Myth Alert 18 January 2011 at 7am

  4. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    On the contributions of media rabble-rousers « Media Myth Alert 26 January 2011 at 6am

  5. […] — would post a reference to one of American journalism’s most enduring and delicious media myths. Not Hearst's […]

    Media myth and Truthout « Media Myth Alert 3 February 2011 at 6am

  6. […] the Remingt0n-Hearst exchange taken place, it would have been in mid-January 1897, at the end of Remington’s lone visit to Cuba in the months before the loss of the […]

    Remembering the ‘Maine,’ Hearst, and Remington « Media Myth Alert 16 February 2011 at 7am

  7. […] Media myths have many uses, none of them necessarily praiseworthy. […]

    Scoring political points with ‘follow the money,’ that made-up line « Media Myth Alert 20 February 2011 at 8am

  8. […] Remington was in Cuba briefly in January 1897. […]

    ‘Furnish the war’ finds a place in sports « Media Myth Alert 28 February 2011 at 8am

  9. […] tale about the Remington-Hearst exchange is surely […]

    Fact-checking ‘Mother Jones’: A rare two-fer « Media Myth Alert 26 April 2011 at 7am

  10. […] those and other reasons, the tale about the Remington-Hearst exchange is surely apocryphal — fiction that too often masquerades as […]

    As if Hearst were ‘back with us,’ vowing to ‘furnish the war’ « Media Myth Alert 10 May 2011 at 9am

  11. […] The tale about William Randolph Hearst’s vow to “furnish the war” with Spain at the end of the 19th century is an excellent example. It’s been around more than 100 years. […]

    Recalling that a ‘debunker’s work is never done’ « Media Myth Alert 20 May 2011 at 5am

  12. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    ‘Too early to say’: Zhou was speaking about 1968, not 1789 « Media Myth Alert 14 June 2011 at 8am

  13. […] Randolph Hearst’s purported vow in an exchange of telegrams with Frederic Remington to “furnish the war” with Spain at the end of the 19th […]

    Why history is badly taught, poorly learned « Media Myth Alert 19 June 2011 at 12pm

  14. […] quote discussed in Getting It Wrong and mentioned by Silverman is William Randolph Hearst’s purported vow to “furnish the war” with […]

    Those delicious but phony quotes ‘that refuse to die’ « Media Myth Alert 25 June 2011 at 10am

  15. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    ‘News of World’ closure breaks link to 19th century yellow journalism « Media Myth Alert 10 July 2011 at 12am

  16. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    BBC calls Hearst vow apocryphal, quotes it anyway « Media Myth Alert 15 July 2011 at 10am

  17. […] in the hearing’s aftermath at least a couple of U.S. commentators turned credulously to a hoary media myth to make points about Murdoch’s supposedly evil ways. Hearst: Made no […]

    Tarring Murdoch with Hearst’s evil ‘vow’ to ‘furnish the war’ « Media Myth Alert 20 July 2011 at 8am

  18. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    He ‘did a Zhou Enlai’ « Media Myth Alert 26 July 2011 at 10am

  19. […] further note in Getting It Wrong that the myth about Hearst’s vow “lives on despite an irreconcilable internal inconsistency: It would have been absurd for Hearst […]

    Media myth infiltrates NYTimes ‘Learning Network’ « Media Myth Alert 13 August 2011 at 12am

  20. […] discussed the hardy media myths that Hearst famously vowed to “furnish the war” with Spain and then made good on the […]

    60 years after his death, media myth towers around Hearst « Media Myth Alert 15 August 2011 at 4am

  21. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    That’s not what Zhou meant « Media Myth Alert 17 August 2011 at 7am

  22. […] that Hearst was the movie’s principal inspiration; the scene paraphrased Hearst’s purported vow, which he supposedly cabled to an artist in Cuba months before the Spanish-American […]

    ‘Kane’ at 70: ‘More relevant than ever’? « Media Myth Alert 10 September 2011 at 9am

  23. […] revisit the tale about “furnish the war” in my latest book, Getting It Wrong, noting that it was first recounted in a memoir […]

    Where do they get this stuff? « Media Myth Alert 24 September 2011 at 5am

  24. […] examples, I discussed the famous tale about William Randolph Hearst’s purported vow at the end of the 19th century to […]

    Accepting the Dicken-Garcia Award for Distinguished Scholarship in Journalism History « Media Myth Alert 12 November 2011 at 7am

  25. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    A thumbsucker commentary and the Zhou misinterpretation « Media Myth Alert 2 December 2011 at 12am

  26. […] tenacity of Zhou’s misinterpreted remark is reminiscent of William Randolph Hearst’s purported vow to “furnish the war” with Spain at the end of the 19th […]

    Apocryphal, but still quotable « Media Myth Alert 24 December 2011 at 7am

  27. […] that is the hoary tale that Hearst, in a telegraphic exchange with Remington, vowed to “furnish the war” with […]

    Sketches published 115 years ago undercut a tenacious media myth « Media Myth Alert 24 January 2012 at 5am

  28. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘Furnish the war’ […]

    Those ‘warmongering’ papers of William Randolph Hearst « Media Myth Alert 1 May 2012 at 5am

  29. […] in answering Remington’s telegram, Hearst vowed to “furnish the war” with Spain, which broke out 15 months later, in April […]

    Renewing the Hearst-Remington association in a $200,000 grant « Media Myth Alert 8 July 2012 at 10am

  30. […] power ever  to dismantle. (See also, William Randolph Hearst’s purported vow to “furnish the war” with Spain; the supposed “Cronkite Moment” of 1968, and the misleading dominant […]

    The Internet’s uneven capacity to expose media fakes « Media Myth Alert 30 July 2012 at 10am

  31. […] my 2000 myth-busting study about William Randolph Hearst and his purported vow to “furnish the war” with Spain. […]

    ‘Not Likely Sent’ article about Hearst’s ‘vow’ a top 50 selection in AEJMC flagship journal « Media Myth Alert 10 August 2012 at 12pm

  32. […] then introduces the “furnish the war” vow, calling it “a fictitious communiqué” that “remains the single-most […]

    Mistaking conspiracy for sloppy history in Hearst’s ‘vow’ to ‘furnish the war’ | Media Myth Alert 29 June 2013 at 3pm

  33. […] back story to the myth is that Remington, a famous artist of the American West, was sent to Cuba on assignment for […]

    The Remington-Hearst media myth invoked anew | Media Myth Alert 19 June 2014 at 11am

  34. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    ‘SF Examiner’ marks 150th anniversary with dose of media myth | Media Myth Alert 11 June 2015 at 3pm

  35. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    No, ‘Salon’ — Hearst’s yellow journalism didn’t cause war with Spain | Media Myth Alert 18 July 2015 at 2pm

  36. […] journalism’s best-known myths, the purported vow of William Randolph Hearst to “furnish the war” with […]

    The Woodward, Bernstein stories that ‘toppled’ Nixon: And they were? | Media Myth Alert 19 July 2015 at 4pm

  37. […] The anecdote of Hearst’s vowing to “furnish the war” with Spain dates back nearly 120 years. It was first recounted in a book of reminiscences by […]

    Media myths: FAQs, Part Two | Media Myth Alert 24 July 2015 at 10am

  38. […] did give rise to the apocryphal tale of Hearst’s vowing to Remington that he would “furnish the war” with […]

    About that Hearst quote on public’s fondness for entertainment | Media Myth Alert 20 August 2015 at 6am

  39. […] war” with Spain in the late 19th century is a zombie-like bogus quote: Despite thorough and repeated debunking, it never […]

    ‘Forbes’ essay invokes zombie-like Hearst ‘quote’: It never dies | Media Myth Alert 22 August 2015 at 12pm

  40. […] the war” with Spain in the late 19th century has become zombie-like: Despite thorough and repeated debunking, it never […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2015 | Media Myth Alert 29 December 2015 at 11am

  41. […] the war” with Spain in the late 19th century is a zombie-like bogus quote: Despite thorough and repeated debunking, it never […]

    Taking stock: Top mythbusting posts of 2016 | Media Myth Alert 28 December 2016 at 6am

  42. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    New year, old myths | Media Myth Alert 15 January 2017 at 3pm

  43. […] empire in 1898, was largely based on fabrications published by unscrupulous U.S. newspapers. (A disputed but revealing story claims that The artist Frederic Remington, sent to Cuba by publisher William […]

    Florida cannibals didn’t discover breakthrough diet secret - National | Globalnews.ca 24 June 2017 at 9am

  44. […] sovereignty in 1898, was mostly formed on fabrications published by unethical U.S. newspapers. (A disputed nonetheless divulgence story claims that The artist Frederic Remington, sent to Cuba by publisher […]

    Florida cannibals didn’t discover breakthrough diet secret - SHORT NEWS | Canada news ,World News, Politics, Economics, Entertainment,Sport,Business & Finance 25 June 2017 at 10pm

  45. […] Often cited as evidence that he did bring about the conflict is the vow attributed to Hearst, which usually is recounted as his having pledged to “furnish the war.” […]

    Roster expands of journos who’ve invoked ‘furnish the war’ media myth | Media Myth Alert 1 July 2018 at 8am

  46. […] anniversary of what is a towering media-driven myth offers an appropriate occasion to revisit the […]

    ‘I’ll furnish the war’: 25 reasons why it’s a towering media myth | Media Myth Alert 10 January 2022 at 9am

  47. […] The ‘anniversary’ of a media myth: ‘I’ll furnish the war’ […]

    News media foment wars? Debunking a superficial history lesson | Media Myth Alert 20 March 2022 at 10am

Comments are closed.